PublishedHistory & Theology

Bagh-e-Fadak: Yahya Arfi vs Hassan Allahyari

باغِ فدک مناظرہ: شیخ محمد یحییٰ عارفی بمقابلہ شیخ حسن اللہ یاری

The complete Sunni–Shia debate on the historic dispute of Fadak, with arguments and sources presented by both participants.

Date
29 August 2026 at 17:13
Format
Debate
Language
Urdu / English
Duration
5:18:40

About this programme

Sheikh Muhammad Yahya Arfi presents the Sunni / Ahl-e-Hadith perspective and Sheikh Hassan Allahyari presents the Shia perspective on Bagh-e-Fadak.

The discussion covers Qur’anic verses, hadith, historical sources, inheritance versus gift, the positions attributed to Abu Bakr and Sayyida Fatima, and disputed narrations.

Sources and further reading

Editorial compilation in progress

Sources mentioned in the programme will be listed after they have been checked and attributed. Guest claims remain distinct from Talk Away’s editorial position.

Transcript

A transcript will be published only when an accurate version is available. Bilingual or trilingual discussions may have a partial transcript or none at all.

Corrections

No corrections have been published for this programme.

Continue exploring